10 Best Live Sands for Your Reef Tank: Create a Thriving Underwater Paradise

To create a thriving underwater paradise in your reef tank, choose live sands like Aqua Natural Oolitic Aragonite Sand (20lb) for its 98% calcium carbonate purity, or CaribSea Arag-Alive Special Grade Reef Sand (20lb) to support beneficial bacteria. Consider LANDEN NanshaPure Natural Sand (11lb) for its phosphate-free composition. Look for grains between 0.03 and 0.16 inches to enhance filtration and prevent detritus buildup. Keep reading to discover even more essential factors for the perfect live sand choice.

Key Takeaways

• Select live sands with at least 98% pure calcium carbonate to promote stable pH levels for healthy reef environments.
• Consider products that offer natural filtration, supporting beneficial bacteria growth for enhanced biological filtration and water quality.
• Opt for sands sourced sustainably from renewable resources to contribute to ecosystem conservation while ensuring safety for aquatic life.
• Look for varieties that minimize initial cloudiness and facilitate quick setup, such as those containing live nitrifying bacteria.
• Pay attention to grain size, as optimal ranges between 0.03 inches and 0.16 inches promote health and reduce detritus buildup.

Aqua Natural Oolitic Aragonite Aquarium Sand (20lb)

Aqua Natural Oolitic Aragonite 20lb Aquarium Sand for Reef, Saltwater and Marine Tanks and Aquariums

• Unsurpassed buffering capability - keeps pH at a stable 8.2
• 98% pure calcium carbonate - no impurities like other sands
• Naturally renewable oolitic aragonite from a sustainable source

View Lastest Price

If you’re setting up a reef tank, consider the Aqua Natural Oolitic Aragonite Aquarium Sand (20lb) as your go-to substrate. This sand consists of 98% pure calcium carbonate, which makes certain it’s free from impurities. Its unrivaled buffering capability maintains a stable pH at 8.2, essential for reef health. Additionally, the sand is sustainably harvested from renewable resources in The Bahamas, guaranteeing compliance with environmental standards. Suitable for all life stages in your aquarium, it fosters a thriving ecosystem. Use this sand to enhance both aesthetics and chemistry, supporting vibrant life and coral growth in your underwater paradise.

Best For: This product is best for aquarium enthusiasts looking to enhance the health and aesthetic of their reef, saltwater, or marine tanks.

Pros:

• Highly pure composition (98% calcium carbonate) ensures no impurities pollute the water.
• Exceptional buffering capability stabilizes pH at 8.2, promoting a healthy environment for marine life.
• Sustainably sourced from renewable oolitic aragonite, making it an environmentally friendly choice.

Cons:

• The 20lb bag may be insufficient for larger aquarium setups requiring more substrate.
• Some users might find it more expensive compared to conventional aquarium sand options.
• Fine particle size can result in cloudiness during initial setup if not rinsed adequately.

LANDEN NanshaPure Natural Sand for Aquarium (11lbs)

LANDEN NanshaPure Natural Sand 11lbs (3L) for Reef or Hardwater Aquarium, Premium Aragonite Cosmetic...

• 【Stabilize Water Quality】Great helps stabilize the water body's pH and KH value. Unparalleled buffering capacity for water quality. LANDEN NanshaPure Sand is a...
• 【Natural Aquarium Filter Media】LANDEN NanshaPure sand is a natural aquarium bottom sand filter. Rich pores and large surface area in the grain structure, it can...
• 【Pure Natural and Safe to Use】Sourced from the pollution-free tropical islands, refined from a mineral variety of calcium carbonate called aragonite, mainly sourced...

View Lastest Price

The LANDEN NanshaPure Natural Sand is an excellent choice for aquarists looking to create a vibrant and healthy reef tank. Weighing 11lbs, this premium aragonite sand enhances water quality by stabilizing pH and KH levels, ensuring your aquatic life thrives. Its rich, porous structure acts as a natural filter, effectively removing impurities like chlorine and nitrate. Additionally, being phosphate-free means it’s safe for all inhabitants. The sand’s natural white color not only beautifies your aquarium but also benefits hard-water-loving species. Use it to foster a thriving marine environment, promoting healthy bacteria growth for ideal filtration and clarity.

Best For: Aquarists seeking a premium substrate that stabilizes water quality for a healthy reef or hard water aquarium environment.

Pros:

• Provides excellent pH and KH stabilization, enhancing overall water quality.
• Contains no phosphates or harmful additives, making it safe for a variety of aquatic life.
• The natural white color enhances the aesthetic appeal of your aquarium while supporting beneficial hard-water-loving species.

Cons:

• May be more expensive compared to regular sand substrates.
• Requires thorough rinsing before use to eliminate any initial dust.
• Not suitable for soft-water fish species, as it may raise carbonate hardness.

CaribSea Arag-Alive Special Grade Reef Sand, 20-Pound

CaribSea Arag-Alive Special Grade Reef Sand, 20-Pound

• Functional and beautiful aragonite substrate for all types of marine aquariums
• Contains millions of beneficial marine bacteria to enhance biological filtration
• Many styles to help recreate any marine environment

View Lastest Price

CaribSea Arag-Alive Special Grade Reef Sand is an excellent choice for marine aquarium enthusiasts seeking both functional benefits and aesthetic appeal. Weighing 20 pounds, this aragonite substrate supports millions of beneficial marine bacteria, enhancing biological filtration in your tank. With a grain size between 0.0393701 inches and 0.0787402 inches, it’s perfect for various marine environments. Choose from multiple styles to replicate specific marine habitats, elevating your aquarium’s look and health. By using this sand, you create a natural environment that fosters the overall well-being of your marine life, ensuring they thrive in a beautiful, functional underwater paradise.

Best For: Marine aquarium enthusiasts looking to enhance both the health and aesthetic appeal of their underwater environments.

Pros:

• Enhances biological filtration with millions of beneficial marine bacteria.
• Available in various styles to replicate different marine habitats.
• Creates a natural environment that supports the well-being of marine life.

Cons:

• May require rinsing prior to use to remove dust and debris.
• Grain size may not be suitable for all fish species or tank setups.
• The initial cost may be higher compared to standard aquarium substrates.

CLASSIC SAND & PLAY Natural Aquarium Sand for Freshwater and Saltwater Tanks (20 lb. Bag)

CLASSIC SAND & PLAY Natural Aquarium Sand for Freshwater and Saltwater Tanks, 20 lb. Bag, Improves...

• Fine Aquarium Sand – A must-have for keeping fish tanks cleaner, our salt and freshwater aquarium sand helps you maintain a cleaner, clearer environment while setting...
• Washed and Kiln Dried Sand – Compatible with personal or commercial aquarium sand filters our fresh and salt aquarium sand is pre-washed to remove any excess impurities...
• Animal and Plant Safe Sand – Along with supporting your sand aquarium filter our fresh and saltwater aquarium sand is safe for different fish types as well as plants...

View Lastest Price

For aquarists seeking an ideal substrate for both freshwater and saltwater tanks, CLASSIC SAND & PLAY Natural Aquarium Sand stands out. This pre-washed, fine sand comes in a 20 lb. bag, ensuring your tank stays cleaner and clearer. Its soft texture enhances aesthetics, with seven vibrant colors that contrast beautifully with your plants and decorations. This sand is washed and kiln-dried to remove impurities, preventing dust and cloudiness—even when burrowing fish dig into it. At 19.45 pounds, it fits well in various aquarium setups, and it’s safe for diverse aquatic species, making it a versatile choice for all your aquatic needs.

Best For: Aquarists looking for a versatile substrate that enhances the beauty and health of both freshwater and saltwater aquariums.

Pros:

• Soft texture and vibrant color options improve tank aesthetics and contrast well with plants and decorations.
• Pre-washed and kiln-dried sand prevents dust and cloudiness, maintaining clear water quality.
• Safe for a variety of fish species and compatible with aquarium sand filters, promoting overall tank health.

Cons:

• Limited to a specific weight (20 lb. bag), which may not be sufficient for larger tanks.
• Specialty substrate may require more frequent replacement compared to gravel alternatives.
• Higher price point than standard aquarium gravel, potentially deterring budget-conscious aquarists.

Coarse Aragonite 10lb Sand for Reef, Saltwater and Marine Aquariums

Coarse Aragonite 10lb Sand for Reef, Saltwater and Marine Aquariums

• Unsurpassed buffering capability - keeps pH at a stable 8.2
• Phosphate free
• 98% pure calcium carbonate - no impurities like other forms of aragonite

View Lastest Price

Coarse Aragonite 10lb Sand stands out as an exceptional choice for reef and saltwater aquarium enthusiasts aiming to create a stable and thriving environment. Its 98% pure calcium carbonate content guarantees you’re using a top-quality substrate, specifically sourced sustainably from The Bahamas. This sand maintains pH at a stable 8.2 without constant chemical adjustments, thanks to its superb buffering capacity. Furthermore, the oolitic aragonite offers over one million square centimeters of surface area for beneficial bacteria, promoting a healthy ecosystem. To use, rinse the sand thoroughly until the cloudy appearance dissipates, allowing for a clearer water column post-installation.

Best For: Reef and saltwater aquarium enthusiasts looking for a high-quality substrate that supports a stable and thriving aquatic environment.

Pros:

• 98% pure calcium carbonate provides excellent quality and stability for marine ecosystems.
• Exceptional buffering capacity maintains pH at a stable 8.2 without the need for constant chemical additions.
• Oolitic aragonite sand promotes beneficial bacteria growth with over 1 million sq. cm of surface area.

Cons:

• Initial rinsing is required to clear the cloudy appearance before use, which can be time-consuming.
• May not be suitable for freshwater aquariums or setups not focused on marine life.
• The product is heavier, which could be cumbersome for some users to handle and transport.

Aqua Natural Oolitic Aragonite Aquarium Sand (10lb)

Aqua Natural Oolitic Aragonite 10lb Aquarium Sand for Reef, Saltwater and Marine Tanks and Aquariums

• Unsurpassed buffering capability - keeps pH at a stable 8.2
• 98% pure calcium carbonate - no impurities like other sands
• Naturally renewable oolitic aragonite from a sustainable source

View Lastest Price

When you’re setting up a reef tank, choosing the right substrate can make a significant difference in your aquatic ecosystem. Opt for Aqua Natural Oolitic Aragonite Aquarium Sand, as it’s specifically designed for reef, saltwater, and marine setups. This 10-pound product is 98% pure calcium carbonate, ensuring no harmful impurities. It comes from sustainably sourced aragonite, backed by an exclusive lease with the Bahamian government. You’ll appreciate its exceptional buffering capabilities, maintaining a stable pH of 8.2. Initially, there may be cloudiness, but don’t worry—the filtration will clear it up, leaving your water crystal clear.

Best For: Aquarists looking to create a healthy and stable environment in reef, saltwater, and marine tanks.

Pros:

• 98% purity ensures no harmful impurities for a safe aquatic environment.
• Exceptional buffering capability helps maintain a stable pH of 8.2.
• Sourced sustainably, adhering to environmental best practices.

Cons:

• Initial cloudiness may occur during setup, requiring filtration.
• Limited to specific types of tanks; not suitable for freshwater setups.
• 10-pound weight may not be sufficient for larger aquariums.

Aqua Natural Sugar White Sand for Aquascaping and Aquariums

Aqua Natural Sugar White Sand 10lb Substrate for aquascaping, Aquariums, vivariums and terrariums

• Triple washed and kiln dried - this is one of the cleanest aquarium sands available, no toxins, no foreign matter, 100% natural sand
• 0.5 - 1mm in size - it has a dense composition and zero fines so does not blow around in your tank
• Ethically and sustainably sourced under license in New Zealand

View Lastest Price

Aqua Natural Sugar White Sand stands out as an exceptional choice for anyone seeking to enhance the beauty and functionality of their aquascaping setup. This 10lb substrate, with a grain size of 0.5 to 1mm, is 100% natural, ensuring a clean environment free from toxins. The triple-washed, kiln-dried process guarantees its cleanliness, while the dense structure prevents displacement. Its stunning off-white color beautifully contrasts with plants, making it visually appealing. Ethically sourced in New Zealand, it’s suitable for aquariums, vivariums, and terrariums, providing versatility for your aquatic landscapes. Choose Aqua Natural Sugar White Sand and elevate your underwater designs today.

Best For: Aquascaping enthusiasts and hobbyists looking for a versatile and aesthetically pleasing substrate for their aquatic environments.

Pros:

• 100% natural, ensuring a clean and safe environment for aquatic life.
• Stunning off-white color enhances the visual appeal of any aquarium or terrarium setup.
• Suitable for various applications including aquariums, vivariums, and terrariums, providing versatility.

Cons:

• May require rinsing prior to use if additional dust is present despite being triple-washed.
• Grain size may not be suitable for all fish species, particularly those that prefer larger substrates.
• Price point may be higher compared to some conventional substrates on the market.

Aqua Natural Galaxy Sand Bio-Substrate for Aquariums (5lb)

Aqua Natural Galaxy Sand Bio-Substrate 5lb for Aquariums, Sand seeded with Start up bio-Active...

• Seeded with bio-active live nitrifying bacteria
• Cycles aquarium instantly
• Contains bio activated live nitrifying bacteria

View Lastest Price

For aquarists aiming to establish a thriving reef ecosystem, the Aqua Natural Galaxy Sand Bio-Substrate (5lb) presents an excellent choice. This 100% natural, sustainably sourced sand is triple washed and kiln-dried, ensuring a clean start for your aquarium. It contains bio-active live nitrifying bacteria to cycle your setup instantly, optimizing water quality. Mix 1lb of this live substrate with 4lb of dry substrate for every gallon of water you use, but don’t rinse it before adding. With a customer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 1,000 reviews, it’s an effective foundation for beneficial bacteria growth.

Best For: Aquarists looking to create a healthy and thriving aquarium ecosystem using a natural bio-substrate.

Pros:

• Promotes beneficial bacteria growth for optimal water quality.
• Easy to clean and maintain with a high-quality substrate.
• Instant cycling of aquariums due to live nitrifying bacteria.

Cons:

• Requires mixing with dry substrate, which may complicate setup for beginners.
• Not suitable for aquarists who prefer fully synthetic substrates.
• Price may be higher compared to regular sand substrates.

Carib Sea ACS00050 Aragonite Reef Sand for Aquarium, 40-Pound

Carib Sea ACS00050 Aragonite Reef Sand for Aquarium, 40-Pound

• 100% aragonite sand supports stable ph
• For use in marine aquariums and hard water freshwater aquariums
• grain size reduces built up detritus

View Lastest Price

Carib Sea ACS00050 Aragonite Reef Sand is an exceptional choice if you’re setting up a reef tank. Made from 100% aragonite, this 40-pound sand supports stable pH levels, important for maintaining a healthy aquatic environment. Its grain size minimizes detritus build-up, promoting a cleaner substrate. Designed to replicate natural reef settings, it helps create that vibrant underwater paradise you seek. Suitable for both marine and hard water freshwater aquariums, its wheat color adds a classic touch. With an impressive average rating of 4.6 stars from over 2,700 customers, you can trust this quality product to enhance your reef tank’s aesthetics and functionality.

Best For: Aquarists looking to create a natural reef aquarium environment with stable pH levels.

Pros:

• Supports stable pH levels, essential for aquatic health.
• Reduces the build-up of detritus with its ideal grain size.
• Made in the USA from 100% aragonite, ensuring quality.

Cons:

• No warranty information specified, which may concern some buyers.
• Limited to a single color option (wheat), which may not suit all preferences.
• Packaging dimensions may appear smaller than expected for a 40-pound product.

AquaNatural Coarse Aragonite for Reef and Saltwater Aquariums (20lb)

AquaNatural Coarse Aragonite 20lb for Reef, Saltwater and Marine Aquariums, Sand

• Unsurpassed buffering capability - keeps pH at a stable 8.2
• 98% pure calcium carbonate - no impurities like other forms of aragonite
• Naturally renewable oolitic aragonite - sustainable sourced

View Lastest Price

If you’re seeking an ideal substrate for your reef tank, consider the AquaNatural Coarse Aragonite, weighing 20 pounds. This sand is 98% pure calcium carbonate, ensuring excellent water quality. It’s sustainably sourced from oolitic aragonite, which helps maintain stable pH levels around 8.2, essential for coral health. Each kilogram offers over 1 million square centimeters of surface area, promoting beneficial bacteria growth. Rinse the sand thoroughly in clean water before adding it to your aquarium to minimize cloudiness, which will clear once your filter operates. This phosphate-free option is perfect for various marine applications, enhancing your underwater paradise effectively.

Best For: Aquarists looking for a high-quality substrate to maintain optimal water conditions in reef and saltwater aquariums.

Pros:

• Excellent buffering capability maintains stable pH levels at 8.2, crucial for coral health.
• High surface area promotes beneficial bacteria growth, enhancing aquarium stability.
• Sustainably sourced and phosphate-free, ensuring quality water and marine life health.

Cons:

• Requires rinsing before use, which can be time-consuming.
• Can cause initial cloudiness in water, though it clears after filter operation.
• Moderate customer rating (3.7 out of 5 stars) may raise concerns about quality consistency.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Live Sand Reef Tank

When you’re choosing live sand for your reef tank, consider the composition and purity of the substrate, as these factors impact both water quality and marine life health. Look into grain size selection, too; smaller grains can enhance biological filtration, while larger grains may provide better water flow. Ultimately, prioritize sands sourced sustainably to support ecosystem conservation without compromising your tank’s performance.

Composition and Purity

Choosing the right live sand for your reef tank is crucial for creating a healthy aquatic ecosystem. First, prioritize purity; look for sands with at least 98% pure calcium carbonate content to minimize harmful contaminants. Opt for sands sourced from environmentally sustainable locations, as these methods maintain ecological balance. Avoid sands with chemical treatments or additives, which can disrupt essential bioactivity. Pay attention to grain size: finer grains can compact, while larger grains enhance stability and surface area for beneficial bacteria. Finally, choose natural sands with a porous structure—they improve filtration and provide habitat for nitrifying bacteria. Making these choices will help guarantee ideal water quality and a thriving reef environment.

Buffering Capability Importance

Buffering capacity’s importance in your reef tank can’t be overstated—it’s essential for maintaining stable pH levels, ideally around 8.2, which supports marine life. Choose live sand that contains aragonite; it releases calcium and carbonate ions to resist fluctuations in pH and alkalinity. Additionally, opt for sand with beneficial bacteria, as it enhances biological filtration by converting harmful ammonia into safer compounds, aiding the cycling process. This colonization maximizes surface area, providing a robust environment for nitrifying bacteria and improving water conditions. With a consistent buffering system, you reduce the need for constant chemical additions, fostering a more natural and stable environment. Select wisely, and you’ll create a thriving underwater paradise.

Sustainable Sourcing Practices

How do you guarantee you’re selecting live sand that supports both your reef tank’s health and the environment? Start by choosing sand harvested from renewable sources, which minimizes environmental impact. Verify it’s collected under regulated leases or licenses to comply with local environmental regulations, safeguarding marine ecosystems. Next, confirm that the sand comes from pollution-free areas; this helps maintain excellent water quality in your aquarium. Be sure to select products free from chemical treatments and artificial additives, protecting the health of your marine life. Finally, remember that using clean, sustainably sourced substrates not only enhances your tank’s biodiversity but also supports the overall health of the marine environment. Prioritize sustainability for a thriving underwater paradise.

Grain Size Selection

Selecting the right grain size for your live sand can make all the difference in your reef tank’s health and appearance. Aim for grains between 0.03 inches (0.75 mm) and 0.16 inches (4 mm). Smaller grains, around 0.03 inches, offer more surface area for beneficial bacteria, enhancing biological processes. If you have active fish, consider coarser grains to minimize detritus buildup and improve water flow. Consistency in grain size is vital; uneven grains can lead to harmful dead spots. Additionally, think about aesthetics—grain size influences light diffusion and visual depth, affecting your tank’s overall look. Prioritize these factors for a thriving, vibrant reef environment, and you’ll create a stunning underwater paradise.

Biological Filtration Enhancement

To create a thriving reef tank, consider the role of biological filtration when choosing live sand. Select live sand rich in beneficial bacteria, as these microorganisms convert harmful ammonia into less toxic nitrates, improving water quality. Look for sands with a porous structure, offering over 1 million square centimeters of surface area per kilogram, providing ample space for bacteria to thrive. Additionally, choose sands designed to stabilize pH levels around 8.2, essential for maintaining a healthy aquatic environment. The natural filtration properties of live sand also help absorb impurities like nitrate and nitrite. Ultimately, selecting the right live sand supports a diverse ecosystem, promoting the health of both fish and coral in your aquarium.

Water Quality Stabilization

When it comes to maintaining a stable and healthy environment in your reef tank, choosing the right live sand is crucial. Opt for sand rich in beneficial bacteria; this helps process ammonia and nitrates, promoting a thriving ecosystem. Look for aragonite-based substrates, as they stabilize pH levels around 8.2, suitable for reef conditions. In addition, live sand’s natural filtration properties absorb impurities like chlorine and nitrites, guaranteeing cleaner water. Moreover, select sand with effective buffering capacity to prevent drastic fluctuations in water chemistry, important for sensitive marine life. Finally, confirm the live sand is free from phosphates and chemical treatments; this prevents unwanted algae growth, contributing to excellent water quality for your aquarium.

Aesthetic Appeal Factors

With water quality stabilized in your reef tank, the next aspect to contemplate is the aesthetic appeal of your live sand. Choose colors that enhance the tank’s overall look; natural whites and vibrant shades can complement your aquatic plants and ornaments. Consider the grain size; finer sands create a smooth, natural appearance while coarser grains add texture. Arrange the sand in varied layers or patterns for depth, making the aquarium more visually engaging. Don’t forget about lighting—proper illumination can enhance reflections and shadows, creating dynamic effects on the substrate. Remember, a well-chosen live sand doesn’t just look good; it fosters beneficial organisms that improve the entire ecosystem’s visual charm.

Compatibility With Aquatic Life

Choosing the right live sand for your reef tank is crucial, as it directly affects the health and compatibility of your aquatic life. Opt for natural materials like aragonite; it’s great for buffering pH and supplying essential nutrients. Verify the sand contains beneficial marine bacteria; these enhance biological filtration and create stable habitats for sensitive species like corals and shrimp. Match the grain size to your intended species—finer grains suit certain fish while coarser grains work for cichlids. Always select phosphate-free options to prevent harmful algal blooms. Finally, consider the sand’s filtering capabilities; quality substrate removes impurities, promoting a healthier environment for all your fish and invertebrates.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Often Should I Replace Live Sand in My Reef Tank?

Replace live sand every 6 to 12 months, or when you notice decreased water quality or algae growth. To do this, siphon out a portion—about 10-20%—during your routine water change, then add fresh live sand, like CaribSea’s Arag-Alive, to replenish beneficial bacteria. Always wait two weeks before adding new livestock, ensuring your tank stabilizes. Keep an eye on coral health, adjusting your routine as needed based on their response.

Can Different Brands of Live Sand Be Mixed Together?

Yes, you can mix different brands of live sand in your reef tank. Just check they’re compatible; look for grains with similar size, around 0.5 to 2 mm, which promotes good water flow. Mixing sands can enhance biodiversity, as each brand may contain unique beneficial bacteria and microorganisms. However, avoid mixing sands with additives or chemicals, as this could harm your tank’s ecosystem. Always rinse new sand to eliminate dust before adding it to your tank.

What Organisms Are Typically Found in Live Sand?

In your live sand, you’ll typically discover delightful dwellers like tiny amphipods, beneficial bacteria, and resilient copepods. These critters, measuring just a few millimeters, break down waste, promote nutrient cycling, and support overall tank health. You’ll also find living diatoms and microalgae, which serve as a food source. To maximize biodiversity, consider brands such as CaribSea or Instant Ocean, which offer diverse microbial communities, ensuring a robust ecosystem in your reef tank.

How Does Live Sand Affect Water Parameters in My Tank?

Live sand helps stabilize your water parameters by providing beneficial bacteria that break down waste, which reduces ammonia and nitrite levels. It also aids in maintaining pH levels, typically between 7.8 and 8.5. In addition, the sand’s surface area fosters a healthy ecosystem, supporting microfauna. Monitor nitrate and phosphate levels regularly, aiming for under 5 ppm and 0.03 ppm, respectively. This balance is essential for a thriving reef environment, so choose your live sand wisely.

Is All Live Sand Safe for Sensitive Marine Species?

Not all live sand is safe for sensitive marine species. Choose a high-quality option, like CaribSea Arag-Alive, that’s specifically designed for reef tanks. Avoid sands with large particles, as they can irritate delicate gill structures in fish and invertebrates. Confirm the product’s packaging clearly states it’s safe for reef environments; this helps maintain proper pH and nitrate levels. Monitor your tank frequently to catch any potential issues early, keeping your species thriving.